20
INTRODUCTORY
letters. First there should be calculations specially devised
as suitable for boys, which they should learn with amusement
and pleasure, for example, distributions of apples or garlands
where the same number is divided among more or fewer boys,
or (distributions) of the competitors in boxing or wrestling
matches on the plan of drawing pairs with byes, or by taking
them in consecutive order, or in any of the usual ways 1 ; and
again there should be games with bowls containing gold,
bronze, and silver (coins?) and the like mixed together, 2 or the
bowls may be distributed as undivided units; for, as I said,
by connecting with games the essential operations of practical
arithmetic, you supply the boy with wrnit will be useful to
him later in the ordering of armies, marches and campaigns,
as well as in household management; and in any case you
make him more useful to himself and more wide awake.
Then again, by calculating measurements of things which
have length, breadth, and depth, questions on all of which
the natural condition of all men is one of ridiculous and dis
graceful ignorance, they are enabled to emerge from this
state.’
It is true that these are Plato’s ideas of what elementary
education should include; but it can hardly be doubted that
such methods were actualty in use in Attica.
Geometry and astronomy belonged to secondary education,
which occupied the years between the ages of fourteen and
eighteen. The pseudo-Platonic Axiochus attributes to Prodi
cus a statement that, when a boy gets older, i. e. after he has
1 The Greek of this clause is (biavopa'i) 7tvktcov kcu ttaXaiarav i<pe8peias
re Kai crvXXrj^eas iv pepei Kai i(f)€t;ris Kat as irecfiVKacn yiyvecxdai. So far as
1 can ascertain, iv pepei (by itself) and icfje^rjs have always been taken
as indicating alternative methods, ‘ in turn and in consecutive order ’.
But it is impossible to get any satisfactory contrast of meaning between
‘ in turn ’ and ‘ in consecutive order ’. It is clear to me that we have
here merely an instance of Plato’s habit of changing the order of words
for effect, and that iv pepei must be taken with the genitives ifedpelas km
avXXy^eas ; i.e. we must translate as if we had iv icfrebpeias re ko\ avXXi]-
£ea)s pipei, ‘ by way of byes and drawings ’. This gives a proper distinction
between (1) drawings with byes and (2) taking competitors in consecutive
order.
2 It is difficult to decide between the two possible interpretations
of the phrase (jndXas dpa ypccroG KaL yeducoG kai dpyvpuv kcu roiovrav tivwv
aXXav KepawvvTes. It may mean ‘ taking bowls made of gold, bronze,
silver and other metals mixed together (in certain proportions) ’ or
‘filling bowls with gold, bronze, silver, &c. (sc. objects such as coins)
mixed together ’. The latter version seems to agree best with naigovres
(making a game out of the process) and to give the better contrast to
‘distributing the bowls as wholes' (dXas nas 8ia8i8dvTes).
MI
passed the
and paido
the geome
Teles, the
geometry
that georm
eurriculuir
‘from desj
I am a su
time, I me
dialogues.’
keep the y
other subj
more fittin
the pupils
think then
or public a
they do no
are altoget
is far from
such subje
them unles
they get t
incapable e
subjects up
tion fixed
practised h
capable of
and speed,
studies lik
diate use J
are rather
philosophy
jects taugh
other respe
to learn gr
1 Axiochus
2 Stobaeus
Hense).
3 See Isoc]
§§ 261-8.