TABLE I. ACREAGE SUMMARY FOR THE STUDY AREA USING
LAND COVER
TYPE
MAGI PRIMARY AND
1978 MAGI DATA
4.6 ACRES/CELL
LEVEL ACREAGE % TOTAL
SECONDARY LAND
1978 LANDSAT DATA
1.54 ACRES/CELL
ACREAGE % TOTAL
USE DATA
DISCREPANCY
BETWEEN SURVEYS
ACRES % ERROR
FOREST
P' +S'
34681
46.6
34235
46.0
-446
-1.3
P'
32068
43.1
+ 2167
+ 6.8
P
32633
43.9
+ 1602
+ 4.9
CROP/PASTURE
P' + S'
10522
14.1
10496
14.1
-26
-.2
P'
11552
15.5
-1056
-9.1
P
11678
15.7
+ 1182
-10.1
WATER
P' +S'
79
0.1
81
0.1
+ 2
+ 2.5
P'
166
0.2
-85
-51.2
P
197
0.3
-116
-58.9
TRANSITIONAL
P' + S'
1571
2.1
1044
1.4
-527
-33.5
P'
1626
2.2
-582
35.8
P
1547
2.1
-503
-32.5
COMMERCIAL/
P' +S'
11893
16.0
8349
11.2
-3544
-29.8
INDUSTRIAL/
P'
14499
19.5
-6150
-42.4
INSTITUTIONAL
P
13477
18.1
-5128
-38.1
MED. DENSITY
P' +S'
11256
15.1
11568
15.6
+ 312
+ 2.8
RESIDENTIAL
P'
10778
14.5
+ 790
+ 7.3
p
10968
14.7
+ 600
+ 5.5
LOW DENSITY
P' + S'
4362
5.9
8591
11.5
+ 4229
+ 97.0
RESIDENTIAL
P'
3675
4.9
+ 4916
+133.8
p
3864
5.2
+ 4727
+ 122.3
TOTAL
74,364
100.0
74,364
100.0
NOTE: THE FIRST ROW OF FIGURES IP' + S') FOR EACH LAND COVER TYPE INCLUDE MAGI ADJUSTED PRIMARY AND SECONDARY
LAND USE. THE SECOND ROW GIVES THE MAGI ADJUSTED PRIMARY IP') LAND USE FIGURES. THE THIRD ROW PRESENTS
THE MAGI UNADJUSTED PRIMARY (P) LAND USE, ASSUMED TO BE 100 PERCENT/CELL
TABLE II. ACREAGE SUMMARY FOR THE RESTRICTED STUDY SUBAREA
LAND COVER
TYPE
MAGI
LEVEL
1978 MAGI DATA*
4.6 ACRES/CELL
ACREAGE % TOTAL
1978 LANDSAT DATA
1.54 ACRES/CELL
ACREAGE % TOTAL
DISCREPANCY
BETWEEN SURVEYS
ACRES % ERROR
FOREST
P' +S'
31911
50.7
31739
50.4
-172
-.5
P
31011
49.2
+ 728
+ 2.3
CROP/PASTURE
P' +S'
9546
15.2
9695
15.4
+ 149
+ 1.6
p
10931
17.4
-1236
-11.3
WATER
P' +S'
79
0.1
81
0.1
+ 2
+ 2.5
p
158
0.2
-66
-41.7
TRANSITIONAL
P' +S'
1231
2.0
1044
1.7
-187
-15.2
p
1463
2.0
-419
-28.6
COMMERCIAL/
P' +S'
5322
8.4
4891
7.8
-431
-8.1
INDUSTRIAL/
INSTITUTIONAL
7.5
-591
-10.8
MED. DENSITY
P' +S'
10749
17.1
11568
18.4
+ 819
+ 7.6
RESIDENTIAL
13.7
+ 1296
+ 12.6
LOW DENSITY
P' +S'
4146
6.5
3966
6.3
-180
4.3
RESIDENTIAL
1.7
+ 299
+ 8.2
TOTAL
62,984
100.0
62,984
100.4
•NOTE THE MAGI (DSP PHOTOINTERPRETED) DATA ARE TAKEN AS THE STANDARD
TABLE III: CORRESPONDENCE OF ERROR RATES BETWEEN LANDSAT AND MAGI DATA
INCREASING COMPLEXITY-
WHOLE AREA
RESTRICTED AREA
FOREST
CROP/PASTURE
WATER
TRANSITIONAL
Cll
MDR
LDR
(-15.2)