323
The number of unclassified and grossly misclassified pixels ’
is high outside of the six sub-areas from which sample points
were taken, indicating the importance of obtaining sample
points from all parts of the study area. Many of the smaller
channels are completely dropped from the images although
scattered pixels of "water" or "point bar" sometimes roughly
indicate their location. As can be seen in the two classi
fied images, "point bars" were detected along virtually all
of the major waterways. This of course did not correspond
to airphoto observations. Because of the small size of
many of the point bar sample areas, and because the physical
form of the point bar often consists of a mixture of unvege
tated ground and small bodies of water, it would be more
accurate to label this class "land-water interface". Thus
large areas are classified as "point bar" in the shallowest
part of Mamawi Lake and along the narrow channels of the
Delta. Because of the small size of the sample areas of
"point bar", many of the sample points included both land
and water.
Certain tendencies become apparent upon examination of
accuracy figures for the three years. Firstly, accuracy of
classification of each unit varies greatly between years.
For example, in the ungrouped analysis, the accuracy of
classification of levees (UNIT = 1) was 38.8% in 1974, 47.5%
in 1978 and 63.2% in 1980. Mud flats varied from 49.5% in
1974 to 76.0% in 1978 and 13.5% in 1980. One possible
reason for the latter remarkably high range is that mud flats
were generally quite wet in 1974 (a high water year), they
were distinct in 1978 (a dry year following several wet
years) and in 1980 (a dry year following two dry years)
succession to grasslands had progressed far enough to alter
the spectral signature although vegetation was still
sparse enough to look like mud flats on the airphotos. Thus
confusion with vegetated classes in 1980 was a primary
reason for the low accuracy of classification of mud flats.
Secondly, the analyses of grouped data had much less varia
tion in unit accuracies than ungrouped data, although the
misclassification of mud flats in 1980 is an exception.
The accuracy of classification of the largest group (levees,
muskeg and shrubbed basins) ranged only 0.5%. This suggests
that this type of analysis may be best suited to analysis of
relatively simple systems and improved through the use of
larger sample sizes.
CHANGE DETECTION
The result of a series of low water years is obvious when
the images in Figure 3 are compared. The class "mud flats",
which was fairly extensive in 1974, had been replaced almost
entirely by vegetation in 1980. Water was classified much
more consistently for 1980 than for 1974, when many pixels
located in lakes or rivers were unclassified. The vegetated
unit was more evenly distribute in the 1980 image than in
the 1974 image. The extent of water bodies had also been
considerably reduced. However, because of the reduced number
of units which had to be used to obtain reasonable accuracies