nt
RESULTS OF THE GEOMETRIC TESTS OF THE OPTICALLY PROCESSED IMAGES
Table (2) shows the results obtained after testing the survey optically
processed image of the test area.
For the control points, the planimetric accuracy ranged from 8 - *27m
when the polynomial contains highest order terms to ó om 283Pm when only
the similarity transformation is used. Witn the corresponding set of check
points, the best planimetric accuracy is again obtained when the highest
order terms are contained in the polynomial. Comparison of the accuracy
obtained after using the linear conformal transformation with that obtained
after using the affine transformation shows that a 3x improvement in
accuracy has been obtained. This clearly indicates that this survey-
optically processed image of the test area contains large affine scale
errors.
Table (3) presents the accuracy results obtained with the precision op-
tically processed image of the test area. In general, the accuracy figures
ranged from § =% 37 to p= 517 m for the control points and 8p = I 59 m
to 6p = i 352h for the check points. In both cases, the highest accuracy
was again obtained when the polynomial contains highest order terms;
while the simple similarity transformation gave the lowest accuracy
figures.
Inspection of the results on this Table reveal the fact that substantial
scale errors also exist on this image supplied by ERIM despite the fact
that optical processing of this image has been carried out to higher
standards. This is evident from comparison of the accuracy figures ob-
tained after using the similarity and the affine transformations.
RESULTS OBTAINED WITH THE RAE IMAGERY
The accuracy results obtained after geometric transformation of the RAE
digitally processed image of the test area shown in Table (4).
For the set of control points, the best accuracy figures were obtained
when the polynomial contained the full 11 terms i:e óy- $595 m. Sy = T 34m
giving rise to a planimetric error of * 80m. The accuracy remained nearly
the same until the sixth term of the polynomial was truncated. A 1.5X
deterioration in accuracy was then experienced. Quite unexpectedly, the
largest r- m. s.e value was obtained when the polynomial was restricted
to the first three linear terms (i.e. to the affine transformation) where
values of &, =f 112 m and §y=2 84 m were obtained in the X and Y directions
respectively with a planimetric error of 6 -t 140m. A noticeable point is
that the affine transformation results are not much better than those ob-
tained with the simple linear conformal transformation.
The corresponding set of check points behaved slightly differently. The
accuracy figures remained nearly the same for almost all non-linear terms
of the polynomial. When only the first three linear terms were used, the
accuracy deteriorated considerably from Sp="T 162 m when 4 terms were used
to 6,.2* 205 m when only the affine terms are utilized. Surprisingly,
the simple linear conformal transformation gave accuracy figures much
“1;