The orthophoto projection program resolves with
practically identical residuals at the control points both
the photograph digitized at 300 dpi and that of 2000 dpi.
Much more evident, from the metric point of view, are the
effects of using or not using breaklines; it is not possible to
consider not using them and rather the previously
discussed problems, regarding their generation in
architectural photogrammetry would deserve a more
profound study to find a suitable solution for the general
case of an arbitrary viewing condition and an arbitrary
object.
The metric characteristics remain however correlated
according. to the normal photogrammetric logic, to the
mean scale of the photograph, the focal length of the
camera, the size of the photograph and on the baselength
of the stereo copy. Considering the memory requirement
problems with digital imagery, obtained by scanning at
2000 dpi, and the their esuberance in definition, one has
to ask oneself wether it would not be more convenient to
work with a smaller scale, with respect to those used in
the survey, for the processing of photographs with the
previously decribed raster analysis. This consideration
becomes more realistic when the deformations, introduced
after the photograph was taken, are corrected with the
help of the grid of crosses included in the camera. The
subject deserves a systematic study in close correlation
with the characteristics of the available hardware and
software.
At this point it may be appropriate to make the following
consideration. The level of scanning necessary in order to
be able to define the used metric pixel for example for
autocorrelation of images is esuberant if the metric
characteristics are guaranteed by the D.T.M. and the pixel
is only used to transform the qualitative information of the
photograph.
2.6 The plots
In our opinion, the stage of output on plotter is the part,
where the limits of the current hardware are met and
where (which is equivalent) costs are a major factor.
The first large limitation is the number of different grey
levels, which are reproduced in the plotting stage. This
number is at least four times smaller than the 256 grey
levels obtained during digitizing, even when using a
thermic printer. This characteristic is very selective in the
field of architecture where the contours of the object are
only a part of the final result. Results of sufficient quality
(with respect to traditional orthophotos and rectifications)
Figure 4 - Rectifed photos and orthoproiections superimposed on the known vector data.
using an Iris Inkjet 6024. j
Anyway, for output on paper, the number of grey levels in
plotting has a larger influence on the result than the
resolution in scanning. In fact, even the printing of an area
scanned at 2000 dpi has characteristics, which make it
unacceptable with respect to normal products of typical
working products of the architectural environment.
2.7 Conclusions
Because of the rapid developments of hardware and
software, even an expert is at the mercy of the market of
informatics and every statement can be outdated in a short
time.
This is however not the reason, which urges us to state
that elaborations obtained from scanned photographs and
successively orthoprojected and rectified with overlaying
of vector data can be extremely useful to architecture.
In our opinion, the most important result of the present
research is, at least for the moment ????, The weak part
of the three dimensional processing of images remains the
output on paper, also from the point of view of metric
precision.
It could therefore be intelligent to have a different
relation with the user of a photogrammetric survey. One
does not have to supply a plot, but, once familiar with its
use, provide a computer based copy of the orthoprojection
and / or the rectification, which is easy to manipulate with
software. The user can then take advantage of the
characteristics of digital images and elaborate grey levels;
he can equalize the images; he can carry out ad hoc vector
based operations and possibly print them on paper,
without running into problems in connection with plotter
characteristics, having only to print only lines and hatched
areas. An example can be the following: an art historian,
using the result of an orthoprojection of a wall of bricks,
wants to study the stucture of the wall. Once the grey
values corresponding to the fugues between the bricks
have been identified, the fugues can be highlighted and
the intensity of the other grey valuescan simultaneously be
lowered. On the video screen appears only the fugue
structure. By entering in editing in these conditions, he can
create a vector based drawing on a suitable layer, which
can be processed separately and which maintains the
metric quality of the orthoprojection.
From this point of view, an experiment is being carried out
with a restorer of a fresco of the Zavattari's in the Chapel
of Queen Teodolinda in Monza's Cathedral, to verify the
applicability of photogrammetry to the field of
architecture.