• Colonna del Tempio di Hera-Lacinia, Crotone (Italy):
Greek Doric column of the last of 48 columns supporting
the temple of Hera Lacinia (500-475 BC). Of the whole
structure, sacked and damaged by the 1683 earthquake,
there remains a single degraded limestone column with its
capital halved. The survey results are used for
documentation purposes and to compare laser range
scanning with traditional photogrammetric techniques.
• Nuraghe Iloi, Sardegna (Italy): The nuraghe lloy is a
complex archaeological building about five metres tall and
consisting of a tower of conical shape, built with layers of
enormous boulders without the use of malt cement. The
survey results are used for documentation purposes,
structural condition studies and visualization.
• Hamburg City Centre: This survey was done in the
context of city modelling and includes 50 scans covering
several streets in the city centre of Hamburg. It shows that
laser range scanning allows to quickly acquire detailed 3D
information of entire streets and even cities. However, it
also shows that for this kind of application the processing
software needs to be highly automated and needs to support
a sophisticated management of the huge amount of acquired
data.
Table 1: A list sample objects specifying their type, the
acquisition hardware used for the survey and the time
required for acquisition and processing.
Surveyed
object
Sagrestia
Archivio
di Stato
Ex Hotel
Colombi
a
Colonna
di Hera
Lacinia
Nuraghe
Iloi
Hambur
g
Geometry
Inside
Inside
Outside
Outside
Outside
Laser
scanner
Cyrax
Callidus
Cyrax
Riegl
LPM-HA
Riegl
Z360
N scans
15
4
11
2
20
Type 2D
camera
Digital
Digital
and
analog
Digital
and
analog
Digital
/
N images
15
30
12
2
/
Time
acquisition
(hours)
8
12
8
8
8
Time data
processing
(days)
4
6
4
2
4
The diversity of the presented objects shows the versatility of
lasers scanning in the field of architecture and Cultural
Heritage. The final 3D models are used for different scopes,
confirming the importance of this technology for conservation,
maintenance and presentation of Cultural Heritage
3. DATA ACQUISITION
The software described in section 4 allows mapping external 2D
images on the 3D mesh, which is reconstructed from the raw 3D
data. Therefore, data acquisition not only refers to object
scanning but also includes the acquisition of the 2D images. It is
also possible (although not necessary) to acquire a set of
external reference points for geo-referencing. Table 1 lists
details of the data acquisition (i.e. type of scanner, time of
acquisition) for each of the sample objects. The remainder of
this section lists some of the lessons we learned during
acquiring and processing the data and could serve as a small
guideline for future scanning sessions.
3.1 3D acquisition
Usually it requires several scans to cover the entire object and
resolve all the occlusions and shadows. The main points to
consider are:
• Occlusion and shadows: the scanning position should be
planned carefully to avoid missing data. Holes and
occlusion become particularly evident if the data will be
triangulated in a later stage. It is useful if the software
gives the possibility to register the acquired scans in situ so
that holes and occlusion can immediately be detected and
resolved.
• Angle of acquisition: the precision of the 3D measurement
acquired with the laser scanner decreases with the
acquisition angle. A shallow angle also produces a low
measurement resolution on the object. To increase the
quality of the final model the acquisition direction should
be as perpendicular to the object surface as possible. For
example, the distance between viewpoints along a façade
should not be too long.
• Overlap between scans: especially feature-based and
point-based registration (see section 4.2.2 and 4.2.3)
require sufficient overlap between scans. For example, the
ICP registration requires about 30% overlap, which also
needs to have some geometrical information in all 3
dimensions (i.e. the overlapping points should not lay on a
single plane). If possible, it is useful to acquire one or more
reference scans at low resolution, which cover as much of
the object as possible and which are then used to register
the detailed scans.
• Uniform scan resolution: scanner viewpoints and
resolution settings should be chosen to yield a fairly
uniform resolution on the object in order to obtain a final
3D model with homogeneous geometrical properties.
• Documenting the acquisition: Especially if the scan are
not registered on the fly, it is important to take note of the
data acquisition scheme both for laser scanner viewpoints
and the acquisition points of the 2D images, otherwise a lot
time might be spent assigning the different scan and
images to each other.
3.2 2D images acquisition
The 2D data usually is acquired with an uncalibrated standard
digital camera. However, it is also possible to use calibrated
photogrammetric cameras to increase accuracy or a different
wavelength (e.g. infra-red) for special applications.
• High quality pictures: the images acquired with the
camera are directly mapped onto the 3D model; therefore
better images will directly result in a better final result.
Special care must be taken to avoid reflections and
shadows and to minimise the difference in exposure
between images. Even though image balancing is part of
data processing (see section 4.5.2), most of the balancing
problems should be avoided during the acquisition phase.
For inside acquisition the use of artificial light can help to
avoid shadows. For outside acquisition, the weather during
- 149 -