C1PA 2003 XIX th International Symposium, 30 September - 04 October, 2003, Antalya, Turkey
242
at an oblique angle from, for example, the triforium in a
cathedral. When the photography is to be used for
rectification or photogrammetry the camera needs to be as
square on as possible to the subject. Also each individual
photograph must have a negative scale commensurate with
the anticipated scale of the final product. As a general rule
the final product should be no more than a six times
enlargement from the negative scale - so a 1:10 scale
orthophotograph would require photography at a minimum
of 1:60 scale. If using a 50mm lens this means the camera
would need to be a maximum of 3 m from the subject. These
constraints can be met in a number of different ways.
Figure 1 Rollei 6006 semi-metric camera set up on an
extension bar with a Macbeth chart in the image.
The most common method is to use an extension bar and a
tripod (see Fig. 1). This allows the camera to look straight
down at the surface of the floor without imaging the tripod
legs. There is, however, a compromise to be made between
the length of the bar and the number of photographs required.
A long bar will allow a photograph without any interference
from the tripod legs but as the bar will tend to oscillate, it
will be necessary to wait a long time after moving the camera
set up (until the camera is still) before taking the next
photograph. The possibility of vibration will also limit
exposure times. A shorter bar will not oscillate but it will be
necessary to take more photographs because tripod legs will
appear in a portion of each photograph. Each strip of
photography will have to be substantially overlapped by the
next in order to achieve complete un-obscured coverage.
Another method of achieving the correct camera to subject
distance is to take oblique photographs from a tall tripod.
Whilst digital rectification software and to a lesser extent
digital photogrammetric systems can accommodate oblique
photography it is not an ideal solution. It should be
remembered that because the photograph is oblique the scale
will vary across the image. Therefore it will be necessary to
either take a photograph where part of it is at a larger scale
than required or to discard part of the image because it is at
too small a scale. Using a tall tripod has its own practical
difficulties. In order to look through the viewfinder the
photographer will require a step ladder and, if the surface is
rough, a colleague to steady it. If the floor is particularly fine
or delicate it will be necessary to protect it from the feet of
the ladder in some way.
If the only suitable camera available has a longer lens it will
be necessary to set the camera further away from the subject
to achieve economical coverage. A camera with a 100 mm
lens could be set up 6 m from the floor in order to produce a
negative scale of 1:60. A vantage point 6 m above a floor
could be found using a scaffold tower or a hydraulic lift. This
sort of equipment brings its own problems, however, and
would only be appropriate in very specific circumstances. An
archaeological site where a floor has been revealed and has to
be recorded rapidly is perhaps one example. Otherwise the
problems of using a hydraulic lift inside a building or moving
a scaffold tower without damaging the floor are probably
insurmountable.
The English Heritage Metric Survey Team generally use a
standard photographic tripod with a short extension bar.
Using a 50 mm lens with the camera about 1.5 m above the
subject gives a negative scale of 1:30, allowing for final
products at up to 1:5 scale. Although good quality
photography is obtained relatively easily this approach does
result in more photographs and therefore more control than
strictly necessary. For most work a Rolleimetric 6006 semi
metric camera is used with Kodak NCI60 colour negative
film. Colour negative is used as opposed to colour
transparency because of its wider exposure latitude. Kodak
NCI60 is a professional film for use in controlled lighting.
Each batch is guaranteed consistent so only film from a
single batch is used on any one project. The NC (Natural
Colours) prefix means there is no particular colour bias and
the very fine grain gives better resolution, although it
requires a longer exposure time. The camera has a reseau
plate fitted and has been calibrated so that it can be used in a
digital photogrammetric workstation (DPW). The use of
calibration information also improves results in Rolleimetric
MSR, the digital rectification software used by the team. To
obtain correct and consistent exposure a professional spot
meter is used.
4. CONTROL
A photographic survey product, be it a single scaled image, a
rectified photography montage or an orthophotograph,
requires some sort of control. This can range from a simple
scale bar through to targets with 3-D co-ordinates.
A single rectified photograph can be produced using only a
scale bar. To achieve accurate scaling in both axes, however,
requires two scale bars or known distances. The distances can
be measured between points of detail on the floor or targets
can be attached. If more than two photographs are to be
montaged together, a grid of targets will be required with at