Although accuracy figures were based on improved cropland in 1986, half of which
the numbers of polygons detected and was created after 1961 and mapped from
classified, experience gained with the Thematic Mapper imagery. The comparisons
interpretation and accuracy assessment show that land of poorer capability for
suggests that higher error rates are agriculture is increasingly being used for
concentrated among the smaller polygons of cropland. Approximately 40% of the land
change. Although not measured for this with a high capability for wildlife use
project, it is believed that accuracy has been developed for agriculture and
levels based on the area of change would another 25% is threatened with
be significantly higher than the accuracy development. Such analyses are only
figures guoted. Therefore, the accuracy possible when recent detailed land use
figures quoted here are likely a low information such as that obtained from
estimate of what would be expected over a Thematic Mapper imagery is combined with
reasonably large area. the analytical capabilities of GIS.
SPATIAL ANALYSIS
Input of Data
The data input operation involved the use
of both mainframe and micro computer GIS
systems. Land use change overlays were
prepared from the interpreted land use
change manuscripts. Coding sheets were
prepared linking the pre and post change
class combination with the land use change
polygons. Unclassified polygons and
topological inconsistencies were detected
and corrected during this preparation
stage. The edges of adjoining map sheets
were checked for omissions, mismatched
polygon boundaries and classification
inconsistencies.
The change maps were converted into
digital form using a drum scanner. The
resulting raster files were then edited to
remove any remaining topological
inconsistencies. The Canada Geographic
Information System (CGIS), a mainframe,
was used to store the map files and
assemble them into files for the three
geographic zones of the project area. Map
files containing all land use change
polygons larger than a few hectares were
downloaded to a PC-based GIS (SPANS by
TYDAC Technologies Inc.) workstation from
which Quadtree map files of changes were
created for each zone. The coding sheets
were compiled separately on the mainframe
into land use change attribute files for
the polygons in each zone. The attributes
were transferred to the microcomputer
workstation by converting them to dBase
III Plus files. The polygons and their
attributes were combined in SPANS for
analysis.
Data Analysis
Digital Canada Land Inventory (CLI) map
data on agriculture, forestry and wildlife
land capability as well as the CLI
"Present Land Use" files were downloaded
from CGIS to SPANS. These data sets were
analyzed along with the land use change
information in order to determine the
degree to which the land use in 1986
compared with the capability of the land
to support such uses.
The methods used in this project for
deriving current land use information from
satellite imagery have proved to be an
efficient means for objectively assessing
the spatial dimensions of progress to
sustainability for various resource
options. For example, in the Peace River
zone, there were almost 20 000 km2 of
DISCUSSION
Imagery
The use of the boreal enhancement
developed by CCRS (Ahern and Sirois, 1988)
was a significant element contributing to
the success of this project. The project
benefitted the most from this enhancement
in the Peace River and Central zones which
are substantially forested. For scenes
that contained a large amount of
agricultural or grazing land, boreal
enhancements tended to appear "washed out"
with less spectral contrast between
various cover types. However, because
numerous images were interpreted for the
same area, any problems encountered with
one particular image were alleviated.
Regarding seasonal aspects of the imagery,
it was observed that images from August
produced the best overall results, in
particular because of the wide range of
distinctive colours corresponding to the
various maturing crops distinguishing them
from other cover types. Images from May
were useful for revealing pasture and
grazing areas. The bare soil associated
with improved cropland contrasted the high
infrared reflectance associated with
pasture and grazing lands. Winter images
proved not only valuable for
discriminating between forested and non
forested field but also for providing
within-field textural information that in
some cases was associated with unimproved
agricultural land use (K).
Method
A visual interpretation technique
incorporating images and maps presented
several advantages and also some
limitations. One advantage of using
existing land use maps was that it
provided immediate calibration for the
land use classes since a large proportion
of each map area had not changed land use
over the 25 year period. Once calibrated,
the focus of the interpretation shifted to
the portion of the Landsat scene which
exhibited spectral and textural
characteristics different from the
unchanged portion. Additionally, the
revised maps provided a up to date
manuscript of all land use as of 1986.
Probably the most severe limitation of the
method was the amount of time and effort
required to create a digital data base
from the manuscript maps. A digital data
base was very important in order that the
362