Retrodigitalisierung Logo Full screen
  • First image
  • Previous image
  • Next image
  • Last image
  • Show double pages
Use the mouse to select the image area you want to share.
Please select which information should be copied to the clipboard by clicking on the link:
  • Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame
  • Link to IIIF image fragment

XVIIIth Congress (Part B2)

Access restriction

There is no access restriction for this record.

Copyright

CC BY: Attribution 4.0 International. You can find more information here.

Bibliographic data

fullscreen: XVIIIth Congress (Part B2)

Multivolume work

Persistent identifier:
1667435949
Title:
XVIIIth Congress
Sub title:
Vienna, Austria 1996
Year of publication:
1996
Place of publication:
Vienna
Publisher of the original:
Austrian Society of Surveying and Geoinformation
Identifier (digital):
1667435949
Language:
English
Editor:
Kraus, Karl
Waldhäusl, Peter
Corporations:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
Adapter:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
Founder of work:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
Other corporate:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
Document type:
Multivolume work

Volume

Persistent identifier:
1667438379
Title:
XVIIIth Congress
Scope:
449 Seiten
Year of publication:
1996
Place of publication:
Vienna
Publisher of the original:
Austrian Society of Surveying and Geoinformation
Identifier (digital):
1667438379
Illustration:
Illustrationen, Diagramme
Signature of the source:
ZS 312(31,B2)
Language:
English
Additional Notes:
Erscheinungsdatum des Originals ist anhand des Copyrightjahrs ermittelt.
Usage licence:
Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
Editor:
Kraus, Karl
Waldhäusl, Peter
Corporations:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Commission Instrumentation for Data Reduction and Analysis
Adapter:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Commission Instrumentation for Data Reduction and Analysis
Founder of work:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Commission Instrumentation for Data Reduction and Analysis
Other corporate:
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Congress, 18., 1996, Wien
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
International Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Commission Instrumentation for Data Reduction and Analysis
Publisher of the digital copy:
Technische Informationsbibliothek Hannover
Place of publication of the digital copy:
Hannover
Year of publication of the original:
2019
Document type:
Volume
Collection:
Earth sciences

Chapter

Title:
AUTOMATIC HEIGHT EXTRACTION FROM ERS-1 SAR IMAGRY Zway-Gen Twu, I. J. Dowman
Document type:
Multivolume work
Structure type:
Chapter

Contents

Table of contents

  • XVIIIth Congress
  • XVIIIth Congress (Part B2)
  • Cover
  • Title page
  • ISPRS Council 1992 - 1996
  • International Archives of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing (IAPRS)
  • Volume XXXI, Part B2
  • Technical Commission II Systems for Data Processing, Analysis and Representation
  • Editorial Team
  • Copyright 1996
  • For Sale after the Congress
  • Foreword
  • Table of Contents
  • FEDERATED MULTI-DATABASE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR GIS INTEROPERABILITY - THE DELTA-X PROJECT Mosaad Allam, Cherian Chaly [...] Ekow Otoo [...]
  • CARTOGRAPHIC ALTERNATIVES IN THE AMAZON CARTOGRAPHIC Engineer: Eliane Alves da SILVA, MSc.
  • GIS TECHNIQUES AND HYBRID PARAMETRIC/NON-PARAMETRIC IMAGE CLASSIFICATION: A CASE STUDY SHOWING THE POTENTIAL FOR SIGNATURE TRAINING AND ACCURACY ASSESSMENT Thomas Blaschke
  • SAR SPECKLE SIMULATION Regine Bolter, Margrit Gelautz, Franz Leberl
  • EXTRACTING SPATIAL INFORMATION FROM DIGITAL VIDEO IMAGES USING MULTIPLE STEREO FRAMES Martin Braess, [...]
  • PHODIS AT - An Automated System for Aerotriangulation Josef Braun, Liang Tang and Rasmus Debitsch
  • THE FUTURE OF SOFTCOPY IN PHOTOGRAMMETRIC MAPPING FIRMS Gary G. Brown, President, Aerial Services, Inc.
  • SISCAM softcopy photogrammetric workstation G. Capanni, F. Flamigni
  • PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT FOR THE TRIANGULATION PROCESS ON LEICA ANALYTICAL WORKSTATIONS BY SEQUENTIAL ADJUSTMENT USED FOR CONTINUOUS QUALITY CONTROL AND DIGITAL POINT TRANSFER Alain Chapuis
  • Defining and Representing Temporal Objects for Describing the Spatio-Temporal Process of Land Subdivision Jun CHEN, Yanfen LE
  • ANALOGICAL EQUIPMENT - ASSISTED DIGITAL DATA EDITING Dr. eng. Gh. CORCODEL, [...]
  • DETERMINING AN INTERCHANGE STANDARD FOR THE NATIONAL SPATIAL DATA INFRASTRUCTURE OF TURKEY Çetin CÖMERT, Gürol BANGER
  • RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEMS FROM LEICA-HELAVA DSW 1 Alex Dam [...] A. Stewart Walker [...]
  • Processing and Display of Three-Line Imagery at a Digital Photogrammetric Workstation Christoph Dörstel [...] Timm Ohlhof [...]
  • VGIS - a Graphical Front-End for User-Oriented Analytical GIS Operations Jochen Albrecht, Hartmut Brösamle and Manfred Ehlers
  • Network Distribution Techniques of the Global 1-km AVHRR Data Set Jeffery C. Eidenshink and Lyndon R. Oleson
  • A MOBILE MULTI-SENSOR SYSTEM FOR GIS APPLICATIONS IN URBAN CENTERS Naser El-Sheimy
  • STEREO-IMAGE REGISTRATION BASED ON UNIFORM PATCHES M. Abbasi-Dezfouli [...] T. G. Freeman [...]
  • ANALYSIS OF THE GEOMETRIC PARAMETERS OF SAR INTERFEROMETRY FOR SPACEBORNE SYSTEMS Rüdiger Gens and John L. van Genderen
  • TOWARDS AN OPERATIONAL DIGITAL VIDEO PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEM FOR 3-D MEASUREMENTS E. Tournas, [...] Dr. A. Georgopoulos, [...]
  • A MODULAR NEURAL ARCHITECTURE FOR IMAGE CLASSIFICATION USING KOHONEN FEATURE EXTRACTION Márcio L. Goncalves, Márcio L. de Andrade Netto, Jurandir Zullo Júnior
  • Integrated Photogrammetric Systems at Science Applications International Corporation Clifford W. Greve, Ph.D., Scott E. Webster
  • DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC STATIONS REVISITED Armin Gruen
  • THE EPOS SPECKLE FILTER: A COMPARISON WITH SOME WELL-KNOWN SPECKLE REDUCTION TECHNIQUES Wilhelm Hagg, Manfred Sties
  • THE DPA-SENSOR SYSTEM FOR TOPOGRAPHIC AND THEMATIC MAPPING Michael Hahn, Dirk Stallmann, Christian Stätter [...] Franz Müller [...]
  • DEVELOPMENT OF A DIGITAL-IMAGE-BASED-PLOTTER AND ITS APPLICATION TO GROUND DISPLACEMENT MEASUREMENT IN THE KOBE EARTHQUAKE Susumu Hattori, [...] Atsushi Okamoto, [...] Tetsu Ono, [...] Hiroyuki Hasegawa [...]
  • Design of a Mobile Mapping System for GIS Data Collection Guangping He
  • SOFTWARE FOR MANAGING COUNTRY-WIDE DIGITAL ELEVATION DATA Franz Hochstöger [...]
  • Evaluation of Several Speckle Filtering Techniques for ERS-1&2 Imagery Yonghong Huang and J. L. van Genderen
  • THEMATIC INFORMATION EXTRACTION IN A NEURAL NETWORK CLASSIFICATION OF MULTI-SENSOR DATA INCLUDING MICROWAVE PHASE INFORMATION. Gerrit Huurneman, Rüdiger Gens, Lucas Broekema
  • AUTONOMOUS AND CONTINUOUS GEORECTIFICATION OF MULTI-ANGLE IMAGING SPECTRO-RADIOMETER (MISR) IMAGERY Veljko M. Jovanovic, Michael M. Smyth, and Jia Zong
  • CONTROLLING AND UPDATING OF 3D - URBAN DATA WITHIN A DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC WORKSTATION Peter Kempa, Eckhard Siebe
  • PROJECT SWISSPHOTO - DIGITAL ORTHOPHOTOS FOR THE ENTIRE AREA OF SWITZERLAND Thomas Kersten, William O’Sullivan
  • IMAGE NAVIGATION FOR EMERGENCY RESPONSE (INFER) Loey Knapp, Senior Systems Analyst, [...] John Turek, Research Staff Member, [...] Patricia Andrews, Project Leader, [...] Christopher Elvidge, [...]
  • A DATABASE FOR A 3D GIS FOR URBAN ENVIRONMENTS SUPPORTING PHOTO-REALISTIC VISUALIZATION Michael Kofler, Herwig Rehatschek, Michael Gruber
  • EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF OPTIMAL DIGITAL MAPPING PARAMETERS Kurt Kubik, Director, [...] Peter Harvey, Director, [...]
  • EARTH OBSERVATION FOR IDENTIFICATION OF NATURAL DISASTERS EOFIND Dr. Steffen Kuntz, Claudia Streck [...] Claudia Kessler [...] Carlo Lavalle [...]
  • 3-D MODELLING OF BUILDINGS FROM DIGITAL AERIAL IMAGERY Jussi Lammi
  • 3D-WIREFRAME MODELS AS GROUND CONTROL POINTS FOR THE AUTOMATIC EXTERIOR ORIENTATION Thomas Läbe, Karl Heiko Ellenbeck
  • Building a Production System to Support the National Digital Orthophoto Program: An Integration Challenge George Y. G. Lee and David C. Hooper
  • Describing Spatial Relation based on Voronoi Diagram in Discrete Space Chengming LI, Jun CHEN
  • MOBILE MAPPING FOR 3D GIS DATA ACQUISITION R. Li, M. A. Chapman, L. Qian, Y. Xin and C. Tao
  • DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC STATION "DELTA" Malov V. [...] Oleynik S. [...] Gajda V. [...] Zotov G. [...]
  • A PC - BASED SOLUTION FOR COMPUTER AIDED PHOTOGRAMMETRIC MAPPING ON ANALOG STEREOPLOTTERS Dragan Mihajlovié, Zeljko Cvijetinovic
  • AUTOMATION IN DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEMS Scott B. Miller [...] Fidel C. Paderes Jr. [...] A. Stewart Walker [...]
  • DESIGN OF AN AIRBORNE INTERFEROMETRIC SAR FOR HIGH PRECISION DEM GENERATION Joáo Moreira
  • SPECKLE FILTERING FOR JERS-1/SAR IMAGERY Masatoshi MORI, Tomonori YOKOYAMA, and Noboru YAMAMOTO [...]
  • STEREOSCOPIC IMAGE PROCESSING USING A DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEM Nobuhiko Mori : [...] Shunji Murai : [...]
  • ERRORS AND TOLERANCES IN THE MAPPING, PHOTOGRAMMETRY, RS AND GIS INTEGRATION Prof, dr. Nitu Constantin, [...] Dipl. eng. Nitu Calin Daniel, [...]
  • A MOBILE OFFICE FOR SURVEYORS. Martin J. Nix, M. Surv.
  • A CORRELATIVE TECHNIQUE FOR CORRECTION OF SHADING EFFECTS IN DIGITAL MULTISPECTRAL VIDEO IMAGERY. Cindy Ong
  • SEMI-AUTOMATIC DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEM ON PC OYAMA Yoichi
  • SYSTEMS FOR INTEGRATED GEOINFORMATION: stages of evolution Morakot Pilouk
  • COST-EFFECTIVE DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRY Frantisek Pivnicka, Vladimir Cervenka, Karel Charvát, Ales Limpouch
  • INDUSTRY TRENDS FOR PC BASED GIS Gordon Plunkett [...] Y. C. Lee [...]
  • METADATA REQUIREMENT FOR GIS: A CANADIAN EXPERIENCE Gordon Plunkett
  • AUTOMATIC TIE-POINTING IN OVERLAPPING SAR IMAGES Arnold BAUER, Hannes RAGGAM, Wolfgang HUMMELBRUNNER
  • ELSM AND GLSR TECHNIQUES OF ARRAY ALGEBRA IN SHAPE MATCHING AND MERGE OF MULTIPLE DEMs Urho A. Rauhala
  • A CONCEPT FOR A NETWORK-BASED DISTRIBUTED IMAGE DATA ARCHIVE Herwig Rehatschek,[...]
  • AIR MASS MOTION REMOTE CONTROL SYSTEM A. L. Logutko [...] N. A. Rosental, V. N. Glazov, K. V. Obrosov, [...]
  • DESCTOP MAPPING AND GIS SYSTEM - DIGIMAP-GeoSET Jerzy Saczuk
  • INVESTIGATION OF AERIAL TRIANGULATION AND SURFACE GENERATION USING A SOFTCOPY PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEM Professor Frank L. Scarpace and Raad A. Saleh
  • PRODUCTION D'IMAGES SYNTHÉTIQUES DE HAUTE RÉSOLUTION POUR LA STÉRÉORESTITUTION PHOTOGRAMMÉTRIQUE par Florin Savopol, Michel Boulianne et Clément Nolette
  • AUTOMATED GENERATION OF COLOURED ORTHOIMAGES AND IMAGE MOSAICS USING HRSC AND WAOSS IMAGE DATA OF THE MARS96 MISSION Frank Scholten
  • OPERATIONAL EXPERIENCES OF DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC SYSTEMS Martin J. Smith and Douglas G. Smith
  • EXPRESSION OF THREE DIMENSIONAL SPACE WITH DIGITAL CARTOGRAPHIC DATA AND COMPUTER GRAPHICS METHOD Takayasu OHTSUKA, Hidehisa TAKAHASHI, Hiroshi MASAHARU, Takashi ISAKA, Yoshikazu FUKUSHIMA
  • IMPLEMENTATION OF A PHOTOGRAMMETRIC RANGE SYSTEM Antonio Maria Garcia Tommaselli [...] Milton Hirokazu Shimabukuro [...] Patricia A. Paiola Scalco, Fernando M. A. Nogueira
  • SELF-ORGANIZING NEURAL NETWORKS IN FEATURE EXTRACTION Mr. Markus Törmä
  • AUTOMATIC HEIGHT EXTRACTION FROM ERS-1 SAR IMAGRY Zway-Gen Twu, I. J. Dowman
  • DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC WORKSTATIONS 1992-96 A Stewart Walker [...] Gordon Petrie [...]
  • DYNAMIC WINDOW SIZE LEAST SQUARES MATCHING FOR AERIAL TRIANGULATION POINTS Shue-chia Wang, Sysh-Hong Chiu, Chi-Chang Tsai
  • A CLIENT/SERVER MAP VISUALIZATION COMPONENT FOR AN ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION SYSTEM BASED ON WWW J. Wiesel, W. Hagg [...] A. Koschel, R. Kramer, R. Nikolai [...]
  • A NEW METHOD OF PHOTOGRAPHIC IDENTIFICATION IN FIELD WORK - EPSA PHOTOGRAPHIC IDENTIFICATION SYSTEM Delin Yang Professor, [...]
  • STATISTICAL TEST FOR EVALUATION OF THE ACCURACY OF DIGITAL MAPS FOR GEO-SPATIAL INFORMATION SYSTEM Prof. Bock-Mo Yeu [...] Prof. Hyun Kwon [...] Researcher Seok-Kun Lee [...] Researcher Dong-Bin Shin [...]
  • DESIGN AND APPLICATION OF SPATIAL INFORMATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR CITY LAND ASSESSMENT Genong Yu
  • A PORTABLE SOFTWARE SYSTEM FOR A DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRIC STATION P. Zatelli, PhD. student, [...]
  • VIRTUOZO DIGITAL PHOTOGRAMMETRY SYSTEM AND ITS THEORETICAL FOUNDATION AND KEY ALGORITHMS Prof. Jianging Zhang, Prof. Zuxun Zhang, Dr. Weiming Shen and Zhihong Wang
  • THE CONTRIBUTION OF INFORMATION THEORY TO DEVELOPMENT OF MAPPING THEORY OF DIGITIZED AIRPHOTOS (Northwest University, China, Zhang Renlin )
  • DIGITAL POINTS TRANSFER FOR AEROTRIANGULATION BY ANALYTICAL PLOTTER G. A. Zotov, L. B. llyin, S. S.Nekhin, [...] S. V. Oleinik, [...]
  • Appendix: Authors and Co-authors Index Volume XXXI, Part B2 - ISPRS Commission Il
  • Appendix: Keywords Index Volume XXXI, Part B2 - ISPRS Commission II
  • Cover

Full text

  
AUTOMATIC HEIGHT EXTRACTION FROM ERS-1 SAR IMAGRY 
Zway-Gen Twu , IJ. Dowman 
University College London 
United Kingdom 
Commission II, Working Group 4 
KEY WORDS: SAR, DEM Accuracy, Range Error, Intersection Angles 
ABSTRACT 
Various aspects of stereo height determinations from ERS-1 SAR imagery are described in this paper. A pyramidal stereo 
matching algorithm is applied on an overlapping stereo pair of PRI and RTM imagery. The factors that influence the DEM 
accuracy are analysed on four different seed points sets. These factors include the ways to select the seed points and the 
geometric constraint conditions for SAR intersection. With this standard approach of stereo matching an accuracy of 78m 
can be achieved for a DEM. It is shown that the accuracy of the DEM is closely related to the range errors and hence the 
intersection angles of the SAR data and that if this error can be controlled a much better DEM accuracy can be obtained. 
Experimental results produce a rmse of about 17 m for four different data sets. 
1. INTRODUCTION 
It is of interest today to study the creation of the Digital 
Elevation Model (DEM) created from the Synthetic 
Aperture Radar (SAR) for it can provide DEMs in areas 
which are not easily accessible to other optical sensors. 
In this field of research, previous work is mainly focused 
on SIR-B. In particular, Leberl and his group have 
written many papers to discuss the subject of stereo 
matching (Leberl,1986a), (Leberl,1986b), and Mercer, 
(1995) has reported on the use of stereo airborne SAR. 
But not many papers have been published regarding the 
DEM derivation from ERS-1 SAR. Compared with SIR- 
B, ERS-1 gives more accurate orbit header information, 
thus it should create a better DEM. 
An alternative method of creating DEMs from SAR data 
insinterferometry. Stereo. SAR is seen as 
complememtary to IFSAR and can be used where 
interferometry can not be applied. Work has not yet 
been carried out to analyse the best condition for 
implementation of stereo SAR. 
In UCL, the work on the ERS-1 SAR has been undertaken 
for a number of years (Dowman et al.,1992a) (Dowman et 
al., 1993) and useful results have ben obtained . The 
purpose of this paper is to report on an investigation 
into the production of DEMs from stereoscopic ERS-1 
SAR data. In this paper, the pyramidal matching 
algorithm is introduced and a new strategy is proposed to 
increase the DEM accuracy tremendously. 
2 PYRAMIDAL STEREO MATCHING 
Compared with conventional optical imagery, SAR has 
poor image quality which is affected by layover, noise, 
and speckle. Thus to stereomatch SAR, there are many 
problems encountered. To overcome these problems in 
UCL, a new approach is proposed to implement a coarse 
to fine pyramidal method. This pyramidal matching is 
called CHEOPS [named after the Great Pyramid of Cheops 
at Gizza near Cairo] (Denos,1992). The CHEOPS 
algorithm is capable of automatically generating the 
shell scripts required to match both SAR and other forms 
of imagery. It does this by interpreting a script 
describing the topology of image pyramids written in a 
simple language called PDL (Pyramid Description 
Language) and then converting this script into an 
equivalent set of executable UNIX shell scripts. In this 
paper, the PDL file is defined to use the Otto-Chau stereo 
matcher for each tier. The Otto-Chau stereo matcher is an 
area-based patch correlation technique which 
incorporates the Gruen's Adaptive Least Squares 
Correlation and a sheet growing algorithm. This stereo 
matcher performed very well in the SPOT imagery (day 
and Muller , 1989). The detail of this stereo matcher can 
be found in (Otto and Chau,1989). For the seed points, 
the CHEOPS uses the random seed points generated in the 
first tier of image pyramid. Some research at UCL takes 
advantage of CHEOPS in dealing with the matching 
problems in SAR image. Dowman et al., (1992b) first 
applied CHEOPS on ERS-1 SAR data with different modes 
and different angles combination. (Denos, 1991) 
implement the CHEOPS on the NASA Seasat satellite 
images of Death Valley, and tried 9 tiers achieve 
coverage of 81% over 1024 by 1024 imagery. 
3. INTERSECTION 
The intersection of ERS-1 SAR in this paper is the 
analytic approach, proposed by Clark to geocode the 
SIR-B imagery in her Ph.D. thesis (Clark,1991). The 
analytic approach primarily utilises two Doppler 
equations (1) (2) and two range equations (3) (4) to 
obtain the solution. 
2(S1-P)(S1-P) 
f = 
DCI MIS1 N- (1) 
2($9 - PXS5 - P) 
f ss up ed 
DC2 A2|S2 -P| (2) 
RI - [Si -P| (3) 
R2 - |S5 - P| (4) 
where imagel and image2 are the stereo pair 
fpciis the Doppler value for imagel 
fpc2 is the Doppler value for image2 
RI is the range distance in imagel 
R2 is the range distance in image2 
S1is the velocity of the sensor for imagel 
International Archives of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing. Vol. XXXI, Part B2. Vienna 1996
	        

Cite and reuse

Cite and reuse

Here you will find download options and citation links to the record and current image.

Volume

METS METS (entire work) MARC XML Dublin Core RIS Mirador ALTO TEI Full text PDF DFG-Viewer OPAC
TOC

Chapter

PDF RIS

Image

PDF ALTO TEI Full text
Download

Image fragment

Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame Link to IIIF image fragment

Citation links

Citation links

Volume

To quote this record the following variants are available:
Here you can copy a Goobi viewer own URL:

Chapter

To quote this structural element, the following variants are available:
Here you can copy a Goobi viewer own URL:

Image

To quote this image the following variants are available:
Here you can copy a Goobi viewer own URL:

Citation recommendation

Kraus, Karl, and Peter Waldhäusl. XVIIIth Congress. Austrian Society of Surveying and Geoinformation, 1996.
Please check the citation before using it.

Image manipulation tools

Tools not available

Share image region

Use the mouse to select the image area you want to share.
Please select which information should be copied to the clipboard by clicking on the link:
  • Link to the viewer page with highlighted frame
  • Link to IIIF image fragment

Contact

Have you found an error? Do you have any suggestions for making our service even better or any other questions about this page? Please write to us and we'll make sure we get back to you.

How much is one plus two?:

I hereby confirm the use of my personal data within the context of the enquiry made.