The analytical plumb line method excels in overall operational convenience.
Because the observational equations are independent of elements of exterior
orientation, one can, if desired, employ multiple exposures of but a single plumb
line (against a black background) to generate a large number of appropriately
distributed images (see Figure 5). By employing light sources of various colors to
illuminate the plumb line, one can conveniently determine the dependence of
distortion on color. Under certain circumstances a laser beam can be made to serve
as the straight line in object space to be photographed.
At DBA we have found the plumb line method to be especially convenient
for the rapid screening of prospective lenses for use in special projects. The method
also formed the basis for the investigation reported in Brown (1971) wherein the
theoretical development reviewed in the first part of the present paper was successful-
ly subjected to experimental validation. Figure 6 shows the arrangement of plumb
line images on a typical plate that was reduced in this previous investigation, one
of the outcomes of which are the results shown in Figure 7. The behavior of the
various radial distortion curves shown in the figure was found to be in excellent
agreement with theoretical expectations. Decentering distortion was also investi-
gated. The experimentally established variation of decentering distortion within the
photographic field was found to be of no practical significance and so is not shown
in Figure 7. However, the variation of decentering distortion with object distance
was found to be somewhat significant. Although a theoretical model for such
variation has yet to be formulated, it appears to be safe in practice to assume that
decentering distortion as calibrated at mid-field can be applied to all points within
the photographic field.
The primary shortcoming of the analytical plumb line method is that it does
not yield useful estimates of x, , y, , c (although x, , y, , unlike c, do appear in the
observational equations, they cannot generally be recovered well). This is not a
serious drawback if use of the camera is limited to non-convergent photography of
points lying close to the object plane on which the camera is focussed. In this
situation, the recovered coordinates of the exposure stations (X^, Y" , Z^) can provide
effective projective compensation for errors in enforced values of x, , y, , c.
Aside from operational convenience, the major advantage of the analytical
plumb line method is that it can, when properly employed, produce a calibration of
radial and decentering distortion to a greater accuracy than is attainable from any
other method. Supporting this statement is the fact that the maximum value of the
standard deviation of each distortion function presented in Figure 7 is under one
micrometer throughout the format.
SIMULTANEOUS CALIBRATION AND BLOCK TRIANGULATION
What we consider to be the most advanced of the methods of camera
calibration developed at DBA Systems involves a process in which all parameters
entering the projective equations are recovered simultaneously, namely: