away beyond a threshold, the bundle adjustment will
be re-calculated to establish a new outer orientation.
4.5.3 Quality Report As little as possible of the
statistical information is exposed to the operator, but
mainly used in the internal self-diagnosis. The
information from the various computations are
saved in log-files if needed for a deeper analysis.
5. STABILITY TEST OF ANALOGUE
HIGH SPEED CAMERAS
In order to get a deeper knowledge of the geometrical
properties of a high speed film camera during the
exposure phase, a stability test of a camera has been
performed. The study was designed out of the
following conditions and questions:
- Which parameters are stable during the
exposure
- Cameras without fiducial marks will be used
- How should any instability be compensated
and handled
5.1 Equipment and Conditions
Two set of cameras were used for the test. Only one of
the cameras were possible to process further because
of exposure problems with the other. A 3D test field
was filmed from two camera stations to achieve a
stereo coverage. The film was digitized with the
TrackEye film scanner and measured. Approximately
70 points were measured in each frame of which app.
55 were common in both left and right image.
Camera: LOCAM, 500 frames/second
Optics: Smitar 10 mm
Digitizing: 6.2 um/pixel (square)
52 Evaluation of the Measured Film
Three frames in the beginning and three frames in
the end were measured by the TrackEye system. Of
these six frames, four were selected for the stability
test; frames number 1,4,90 and 91.
The stability test was carried out as three separate
parts:
i A separate calibration on the data from each
image frame
ii A calibration on frame 1
and an outer orientation using bundle
adjustment on frame 1 followed by a 3D
calculation of frames 1,4,90 and 91 with fixed
outer orientation parameters. The mean
deviation from the known points were
compared.
iii A calibration on frame 1
and an outer orientation using bundle
adjustment on each frame with the principal
point as unknown. A 3D calculation of each
frame with the orientation parameters and
the principal point from its outer orientation
computation.
5.3 Separate calibration of each camera
The camera were calibrated on a known test field
with 55 points in one plane and 30 points in various
positions separated from the plane. The purpose of
the test was to find out which parameters were stable
during a whole image sequence and between
sequences.
The calibration parameters were computed as a single
point resection in space with the parameters as extra
unknowns. The calibrated parameters were
- principal distance [pixels]
- principal point [pixels]
- radial distortion coeff., separated in x and y
- scale difference between x and y
table 1 Calibration Parameters
The result from the calibration shows the following
characteristics:
53.1 Principal Distance The principal distance
seems to be stable during one sequence and fairly
stable between to sequences. It is not known if the
camera were accidentally moved or re-focused
between the two camera positions. The difference is
small enough to be regarded as noise. The deviations
referres to the first frame.
Principal Distance [pixels]
Frame 1 4 90 91
PD PD dev PD dev PD dev
Pos1 1639.4 1639.8 +0.4 1639.2 -0.2 1638.4 -1.0
Pos2 1635.0 1634.4 -0.6 1634.1 -0.9 1634.8 -0.2
table 2 Principal Distance
5.3.2 Principal point The principal point is, as
expected, not stable between different frames. This is
probably due to the digitizing process, but how large
parts that are coming from the optical system is
impossible to say. The original idea, to calibrate the
principal point for each frame, seems to be necessary.
The deviations referres to the first frame.