3D DETAILED RECONSTRUCTION OF A DEMOLISHED BUILDING BY USING OLD PHOTOGRAPHS
C. loannidis, C. Potsiou, J. Badekas
Laboratory of Photogrammetry, N.T.U. of Athens, Greece
Commission V, Working Group 4
KEY WORDS: Architecture, Cultural_Heritage, Rectification, Reconstruction, Restitution, CAD, Close_Range,
Non_metric
ABSTRACT
In many cases, when the restoration or the rebuilding of impotrant old buildings, that are partially or totally destroyed, is
needed, or when the documentation of destroyed monuments is attempted, old amateur pictures usally consist the most
significant source of information. The lack of control points or other metric information makes the use of such pictures
very difficult or even impossible for the compilation of detailed, high-accuracy plans. The structure of the building/object
and the availability or not of some additional information play a critical role for a successful result.
In this paper, an application on an already demolished 3
-floor building of interesting architecture is presented. The
combination of old airphotos, old terrestrial amateur pictures and some old plans of parts of the building, gave a 3D digital
detailed restitution of the building by applying analytical and digital photogrammetric methods and using a CAD package.
The whole proceedure and methodology followed are given and the graphic results together with the degree of accuracy
achieved are shown.
1. INTRODUCTION
The compilation of a proper, detailed and reliable survey is
of great importance for the study, conservation, protection
or restoration of any type of monument. In the case that
the particular monument does not exist any more, the
compilation of the plans based on measurements and
interpretation of old imagery seams to be the only solution.
Yet, in most of these cases the images have been taken
by amateur cameras for various purposes and above all
no control points or other geodetic measurements are
available.
A similar situation is of a building that in the past was used
as the Town Hall of Pireas, the greatest harbour of
Greece, very close to Athens. This building was founded in
1869, by the seaside close to the central harbour, and its
construction was finished by 1874. It was a big 3-floor
building of significant architecture. Its longest dimensions
were 22.65 x 27.90 m, its ceilings were of varying hights
and in the center there was a small tower-clock (see
Figure 1). Since 1885, until its demolition in 1968, it used to
be the Town Hall and the Municipality Services Building.
Today, at the same area there is a park.
In 1994 the new local authorities have planned a project to
rebuild the old building at its original location following its
initial shape, size and architecture. For the better study of
the project, a digital 3D representation of the building was
decided to be necessary. Also detailed facade plans of all
sides and horizontal sections in desired levels were of
crusial importance for the reconstruction. The only
possible solution for the achievement of these plans is the
“photogrammetric” use of some existing old amateur
pictures / post-cards of the early time of the building,
which were found in the municipality archives and in other
private collections.
2. COLLECTION OF AVAILABLE INFORMATION
The first step of this work was the research of any existing
available information/material that might contribute to the
definition of the metric information concerning the building.
The systematic and careful research of all possible
16
sources of information (that is the Historical Archive of the
Municipality of Pireas, private collections, special
exibitions, antique shops, old airphotos of the area of
interest, old urban planning maps etc) resulted to the
followings:
a. Several close-range amateur pictures, most of them
post-cards, of the 4 sides of the building, taken from
various points of view, on various scales and on dates
varying from the beginning of the century until the date
of the building's demolition. The most important of them
were properly magnified and reproduced, so that
reliable measurements were taken:
- two of them were of the southern side
- one of the northern side
- one of the western side
- one of the eastern side
- one of the northeastern side and
- one of the southeastern side
b. vertical and oblique airphotographs of the area during
the period of the 1950's and the 1960's. Only one pair
of vertical airphotographs was proved useful for
photogrammetric measuring. It was taken in 1965, at a
scale of about 1:6.000
c. paper photocopies of six old plans of the building, in
moderate condition, which are:
- topographic diagram of the area of the building at a
scale of 1:100, compiled in 1957
- facade plan of the eastern and western side of the
building at a scale of 1:50, compiled in 1921
- plan of the southern facade at a scale of 1:50,
compiled in 1921
- old planimetry of the basement at a scale of 1:50,
which was done as a proposal for changing the use
of the building from Town Hall to a Nautical Museam
- planimetry of the internal area of the first floor at a
scale of 1:50
- planimetry of the internal half area of the second floor
at a scale of 1:50.
It must be mentioned that the two existing old plans of the
facades have serious differences when compared with the
related photographs, the most important of them are
referred to
e the construction which existed on the upper part of the
western side and is not shown on the facade plans
International Archives of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing. Vol. XXXI, Part B5. Vienna 1996
e the wind
western :
e the struc
ones on |
e the struc
clock, wl
e certain d
e certain d
Besides, no
was found.
3. PHOT
The determ
coordinates
the correcti
accomplishe
e analytica
e digital re:
the amat
3.1 Analyti
The X, Y, 2
of the buildit
of airphotos
various high
determined.
analytical pF
of the stere:
measured b:
a few cen