happens mostly unconsciously except during experiments set up in the study
of optical illusions. To day, optical illusions are considered to support
the Gestalt theory. The misinterpretation of the visual sensation is caused
by the interaction between the elements of the image, proving that the whole
is experienced and is different from the quantitative sum of these elements.
J. The impact upon visual image interpretation.
As already discussed, the first perception of a photographic
image happens in a similar way as watching television. Only after the differen-
tiation of the Gestalt, systematic "reading" becomes operational. The Gestalt-
abilities have many advantages. Similar shapes and patterns may be recognized
and grouped easily even without a previous identification of the composing
parts.Structures which are only partially registered may be completed and
recognized. Coherent, compact, regular and geometric shapes, having a distinct
boundary and a high contrast, are considered as "foreground" objects and are
always differentiated first. On small-scale imagery (satellites) they consist
of landforms, water surfaces and larger vegetation units. On large-scale image-
ry (aerial photographs) they consist of all anthropogenic constructions,
the vegetation- land use pattern, road-network and tree rows or-patterns,
as shown by their proportion of recognition in the index of differentiation
(table I). The index of differentiation is a simple measure and expresses the
ratio of the total number of features to the total number of images observed
by a group of students. In the test, all features has been written down in the
chronology of their recognition. No significant differences were found between
the indices of satellite imagery (Landsat, Seasat ; different Spectral bands)
and aerial photographs (different scales and emulsion-types).
TABLE I : Index of differentiation, nature of the features recognized and
their proportion in the differentiation (9) for different image-
types. (Further explanation, see text).
Nature of the features differentiated upon : satellite aerial
imagery photographs
Land form 45,5 3,0
Vegetation/Land use 12,5 16,9
Water bodies (surfaces) 11,6 2,8
Towns agglomerations, cities 4,5 2,8
Parcelment 0,9 5,5
Rivers, canals 10,7 6,6
Roads, streets, railways 2,7 42,6
Anthropogenic constructions : industries, 0,9 19,5
bridges, parking-lots, chimneys.
Tree rows, isolated trees, orchards 0,0 12,4
Isolated houses, farms 0,0 2,4
Marks (fault lines, soil marks, agric.marks) 1,8 5,3
Shadows 1,8 1,6
Clouds, haze 4,5 0,0
Snow 2,7 0,0
Index of differentiation 10,18 13,66
On the contrary, the nature of the features which were differentiated varies
a lot. Finally, the gradual differentiation makes it "natural" to start with
macro-units and go on with micro-units, thus proceeding from small-scale
reconnaissance to large scale detail.
Disadvantages are mainly residing in faulty image completion
especially for "geometric" image elements which are used to build "anthropoge-
nic" or other "logical" structures which aren't really there.
200
Mor
nor
tic
nan
it
as
met
bee
ver
are
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
one
(a)