118
the south and west respectively, are different basically because
they contain mixed coniferous-deciduous forests rather than closed
canopy black spruce (see Fig. 6).
- Section B.10, the lake Nipigon basin which is entirely surrounded
by higher land may well be distinguishable from surrounding
Sections simply on the basis of physiographic differences. Such
differences, combined with the rather uniform, predominantly
black spruce forest, may also contribute to detection and delinea
tion from surrounding Sections. Section B.10 was also detected
and delineated on the NOAA-2 image (see Fig. 7).
The following additional boundaries as determined by Rowe were
recognized only on the NOAA-2 image:
- Section B.8, a relatively level plateau with a predominant cover
of jack pine (.Finns bariksiana Lamb.) with black spruce in mixture
or predominating on poorly drained soils.
Separation from Sections B.22a to the northwest and
B.ll to the southwest is probably due to more rugged relief
in both, and to the uniform forests of the former (see Fig. 7).
In an attempt to increase the amount of information provided by the
maps produced, the forest boundaries as recognized on ultra-small-scale
photography (Nielsen and Wightman, 1971) were transferred onto the mosaics.
It was hoped that these boundaries could then be recognized and further
followed across the mosaic. The attempt failed.
CONCLUSIONS
Although ERTS-1 imagery permitted mapping of the boundaries of some
of the major forest types, its use in this application is more limited than
had been expected. A significant factor in this limitation was the
inconsistency of the imagery. Differences in quality were very pronounced
among black-and-white as well as among colour scenes. These qualitative
differences were due primarily to a combination of variables related to image
reproduction and date of data acquisition.
These problems do not appear when much smaller scale images such as
those obtained daily by NOAA-2 are used. The homogeneity of the image over
large areas is a definite asset.
It is stressed again that the images used for the study were
standard products as provided to any user in Canada. Furthermore, the
conventional photo-interpretation method used may have limitations, but at
this time, appears to be the only realistic approach for such an undertaking.
As more imagery becomes available and quality controlled mosaics are produced,
it is conceivable that the results of classifications of this sort will
improve.