776
by its cleared appearance from the single-date maps. Its ground resolution,
on the other hand was degraded due to the necessity of registering twelve
images with resulting discontinuity in reproduction of narrow objects (small
rivers and roads).
The multiband and multidate comparisons of the mean vectors (f and
their dispersions are summarized for selected classes in Table 1. Accuracy
estimates of classification are presented in confusion matrices (Tables 2-5).
Only three ground classes (agricultural land, coniferous forest and deciduous
forest) were included in accuracy analysis because the areas (number of
pixels) of the remaining four classes were not large enough to enable
meaningful estimates. The omission errors and overall classification
accuracies are summarized in Table 6.
As was expected, classification accuracy varied significantly as a
function of the date of image acquisition. The lowest overall accuracy of 67
per cent was obtained for October 6 ERTS scene. Understandably, this was
caused by low accuracy in classification of forest classes especially the
deciduous forest with most stands at the peak of fall leaf coloration at that
time. Fifty-two per cent of pixels classified as deciduous forest in this
scene were overestimated. The September 5 image yielded the overall accuracy
of 81 per cent - the highest for single-date images. The multidate
classification resulted in overall accuracy of 83 per cent thus improving the
best single-date image by 2 per cent only. However, one could expect a more
significant improvement if the images included in the multidate classifier
were selected on the basis of class spectral patterns (Table 1) rather than on
the basis of their availability. With ERTS in the third year of its operation
(exceeding all expectations) the selection of suitable images should be easier
as more of them become available. Presently we plan to repeat the multidate
classification of the Larose Forest test area with another image combination
which includes one winter scene. As was said before, further improvement can
be expected by inclusion of the spatial image signatures.
It can be concluded that multidate classification of the ERTS
digital images is both practical and most promising for thematic mapping of
broad land cover classes. This is especially important in view of greatly
improved ground resolution in the ERTS-C and EOS satellites planned to be
launched in 1978 and 1979 respectively. There is little doubt that thematic
mapping from orbital platforms will have an important role in mapping natural
resources and monitoring their dynamic changes.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Mr. T.F. Potts and Dr. L. Scherk from Computing Devices Company
Ltd., under contract to the Canadian Forestry Service, were instrumental in
development of classification software. Their contribution to this study is
gratefully acknowledged.