C1PA 2003 XIX th International Symposium, 30 September - 04 October, 2003, Antalya, Turkey
538
2.1 Topographic survey
An appropriate network has been applied in all cases of the
study; vertices and topology have been projected to guarantee
the collimation of all necessary points to describe form and
geometry of the structure. Survey of details is an onerous phase
in old buildings: the problem of measuring is moved to criteria
of point selection. In the process of measurement, the elements
deriving from it have enabled a location of the points and the lines
in the space. The approximation grade is linked with a significance
and a quality of the selected points. Very often a design attenuates
or accentuates the geometry leading to formulation of the erroneus
interpretation: non-respected alignments, forced or non-measured
symmetries.
A total station, without reflecting prism, has been the instrument
most used used in this kind of survey. Free from the requirement
to signal the points to be located, it became possible to concentrate
on the selection of the same; this imposes an accurate plan of
measurement of a detail. In such a way it avoids the risk of not
having sufficient data to describe the shapes or, on the contrary, to
have an amount of information requiring costly and patient work
on simplification of the graphic design. During the recognition
phase, drafts have been issued with points, duly numbered and
linked among them; these points should lead to a signifcant line.
In the subsequent acquisition stage, the possibility of using an
identification code allowed the pre-management of the data
into files that group the families of the points and that have
been memorized at different layers in order to facilitate the
management in cad software. File management is fundamental:
a subject is described by means of the points among which the
linear interpolation is programmed; a descriptive structure that
derives from there defines wireframe lines, so an operator decides
what should be in-between the lines. The same lines are, therefore,
a result of the choices aimed at the creation of a model that, as
always, is a simplification and so a scheme of reality, furnished by
a sufficient descriptive accuracy in order to respond to the research
objectives. It is advisable to work with a very clear project with
regard to a data bank that, step by step, is being implemented. In an
tree shaped organisation, for example, it is possible to distinguish
the lines of different nature: structural, wall apparatus, the profiles
of ornaments and decorations etc..., changing the rules, already
consolidated ones, of photogrammetric acquisition from the
observation of the model to observation of the reality.
2.2 Photogrammetric survey
As well-known, photogrammetry has numerous positive attributes
in architectural recording, however there are some limitation of
the photogrammetric product that digital techniques allow us to
overcome. In any case a vast volume of primary data is quickly
captured and the problem of chosing what kind of data, geometric
or thematic, has to be plotted, is posticipated and can be discussed
in the laboratory in accordance with the users survey. Digital image
processing has simplified the pratical approach to photogrammetric
survey in such a way that even non experts in photogrammetry can
perform the plotting and interpretation phases. So, while geometric
problems can be understood by photogrammetrist, the other aspects
of the survey can be performed by conservation specialists.
With digital techniques it is possible to distinguish acquisition
unit (images, coordinates to orient acquired images, measure and
computation to estimate orientation parameters), from restitution
unit (finding interesting points, classifying information in logical
levels representing results in an efficient way). All the topics of the
acquisition unit requires a specific technical expertise and can be
correctly designed and executed by the photogrammetrist.
In the same way all the topics of restitution units can be performed
by the operators who can study other heritage aspects indipendently
from the acquisition and orientation phases.
Another simplification has been introduced with a return to direct
photogrammetry in which the absence of control points allows
to face up to emergency survey where the necessity to collect on
the field, as much information as possible, as quickly as possible,
is often conflicting with high quality metric results. We present
one example, as work in progress, of this direct photogrammetry
application.
2.3 Image rectification
To the necessary critical selection that makes a measurement and
the graphic design an instrument of immense use have also been
added the valuable characteristics of a photo. A passage from
analogical to digital allows, nowadays, the more flexible use of
a photo imaging that releases a complete and “global memory”
in camparison to analytical designs achieved by topographic
measurement.
Aiming at a reduction of field work, and in order to document in
the best possible way the metric difference of the surfaces, digital
rectification can be used thanks to which it is possible to define in
detail the values achieved outlining the areas where the contours
have been measured by topographic or photogrammetric use of
points. A rectified image can be used to integrate the other kind
of information either in evaluation of the surface conservation
state or in 3D model texturing deriving from photogrammetric
restitution.
We present one example of rectified image use to furnish a
base to analyze the wall texture of Povil Casaforte (Aosta) in a
stratigraphic study of the facades.
3. OUTPUTS
The most commonly applied products in cultural heritage
continues to be the line drawing produced from topographic or
photogrammetric plotter, normally at 1:20 or 1:50 scale. In these
products we have to pay attention to the quality of the drawing;
to obtain a useful drawing for conservation requests is demanding
for the operator and can be achieved in practice by working with
large scales. A key change in working methods has taken place
relating to the digital capture of data, making the outputs of the
photogrammetric process much more flexible. Another implication
of this change is that output as three dimensional model is now
commonplace.
The rectified photography method continues to provide a valued
product as a base for a thematic survey or as a texture for 3D
model while true digital orthophoto (Boccardo et al., 2001) is
becoming a powerful instrument of representation in architectural
application thanks to a new approach which uses several images
and a DDEM (Dense DEM) of the object in order to produce
an orthogonal projection of complex objects. It is necessary
to remember as in the heritage field, photography (image) is a
record of great significance. At the very large scale extracting
information is problematic and the object complexity requires
personal interpretation. A new digital product, a stereo-photomap
(Dequal et al., 1999) is now available to explore direclty the
photogrammetric model. All the images of a block, previously
oriented, can be explored as a unique large stereomedel. This new
instrument allows the conservator “to navigate” around a building
without any need of a preliminary restitution: they can select and
measure directly only what is interesting for their study. Just as
with the long history of photo-interpretation, direct stereoscopic