As in the other applications discussed here, these remote sensing-derived
area data can be combined with ground plot data to produce more precise
forest parameter estimates and estimates for smaller administrative regions.
An alternative, is to use the remote sensing data directly with ground data to
estimate or simulate a complete set of measurements for all sample plots,
satellite picture elements, or forest stands/compartments. Such an approach
has been suggested by the work of Poso and Simila (1987, and personal
communication), Tomppo (1987, and personal communication), and Hagner
(1989, and personal communication). Estimates of many kinds could then be
produced independent of an initial cover type stratification/classification
strategy.
The degree of detail in cover type specification will likely be limited initially
as compared to the degree of detail currently obtained on NFI ground plots
regarding tree species mix, stocking density, and tree size or cutting class.
This detail should improve with further research on remote sensing
information extraction and on related estimation techniques for linking plot
and stand data with remote sensing data. Similar comments can be made
about determining detail regarding the cause or type of change, when a
change is detected.
Based on this review of previous, and on-going work, it is likely that the
sample variance of many forest parameter estimates now made will be
lowered when remote sensing cover type information is used together with
the current NFI ground plot data. Use of remote sensing data will also enable
more localized estimates by, in effect, increasing the area subjected to some
form of measurement. Recent satellite/ground data-based simulation results
at the stand (e.g., Hagner 1989 and 1990) , and higher (e.g., commune -
Tomppo 1990) levels of aggregation have shown reasonably good agreement
will standard reference data.
Other findings include (1) a trend towards the use of automatic image
segmentation (e.g., Tomppo 1989 and Hagner 1990) to improve results over
pixel-wise classification. (2) As with clear-felling, cloud cover has been
found to be a major problem in some areas of Sweden, reducing the
availability of cloud-free scenes from a given satellite sensor system to one
every three to five years. Thus it is likely that a robust system should be
flexible enough to mix sources of satellite data and to substitute other sources
of cover type information, such as recent map, photo, and ground data, when
required. (3) The capability exists in Sweden for use of very large scale
photography (greater than 1:2,000) scale for extending the sample for
computer class training and subsequent stratification verification. (4)
Capability exists for detection of major cover type change in satellite data in
Sweden. However, detection of more subtle changes will require more
research in calibration for haze effects by band, understanding the
relationship between canopy structure and spectral reflectance, changes in
ground plot layout and measurements that will give data more directly
corresponding to spectral reflectance or emission phenomena, image
segmentation for change, change detection and estimation using different
sources of data, and the development of an integrated procedure for
detecting and labelling many types of change. (5) Radar and lidar hold
potentially important possibilities for stand characterization, but require
much more research before operational use can be planned.
Forest Area Subjected to Thinning
411