Full text: Papers accepted on the basis of peer-reviewed abstracts (Part B)

In: Wagner W., Szekely, B. (eds.): ISPRS TC VII Symposium - 100 Years ISPRS, Vienna, Austria, July 5-7, 2010, IAPRS, Vol. XXXVIII, Part 7B 
SUB-PIXEL PRECISION IMAGE MATCHING FOR DISPLACEMENT MEASUREMENT 
OF MASS MOVEMENTS USING NORMALISED CROSS-CORRELATION 
Misganu Debella-Gilo 1 and Andreas Kaab 2 
'^Institute of Geosciences, University of Oslo, P. O. Box 1047, Oslo, Norway 
1 m.d.gilo@geo.uio.no (corresponding author), 2 kaeab@geo.uio.no, 
KEY WORDS: Normalised cross-correlation, Sub-pixel, Image matching, Displacement measurement, Rockglacier, Glacier, Rock 
slide 
ABSTRACT: 
This study evaluates the performance of two fundamentally different approaches to achieve sub-pixel precision of normalised cross 
correlation when measuring surface displacements on mass movements from repeat optical images. In the first approach, image 
intensities are interpolated to a desired sub-pixel resolution using a bi-cubic interpolation scheme prior to the actual displacement 
matching. In the second approach, the image pairs are correlated at the original image resolution and the peaks of the correlation 
coefficient surface is then located at the desired sub-pixel resolution using three techniques, namely bi-cubic interpolation, parabola 
fitting and Gaussian fitting. Both principal approaches are applied to three typical mass movement types: rockglacier creep, glacier 
flow and rock sliding. Their performance is evaluated in terms of matching accuracy and in reference to the images of the resolution 
they are expected to substitute. Our results show that intensity interpolation using bi-cubic interpolation (first approach) performs 
best followed by bi-cubic interpolation of the correlation surface (second approach). Both Gaussian and parabolic peak locating 
perform weaker. By increasing the spatial resolution of the matched images by intensity interpolation using factors of 2 to 16, 40% to 
80% reduction in mean error could be achieved in reference to the same resolution original image. 
1. INTRODUCTION 
Present climatic change shifts geomorphodynamic equilibriums 
and intensifies related mass movement processes such as 
landslides and permafrost creep (Haeberli and Beniston 1998; 
Rebetez et al. 1997). Extension and intensification of human 
activities in areas affected by such mass movements increase 
the probability of connected adverse impacts like natural 
hazards or building stability problems. The consequently 
growing needs for monitoring mass movements are 
complemented by growing remote sensing opportunities for 
doing so. The increasing number of available stacks of multi 
temporal space-borne, air-borne and terrestrial images, and the 
improvements in remote sensing and image processing in 
general significantly enhance the potential for applying 
matching techniques to detect and quantify earth surface mass 
movements from repeat remotely sensed data. All the above 
needs and developments call for continued efforts to improve 
terrain displacement matching methods based on repeat images. 
Image matching is a group of techniques of finding 
corresponding features or image patches in two or more images 
taken of the same scene from different viewing positions, at 
different times and/or using different sensors (Zitova and 
Flusser 2003). Image matching is among others used for a large 
variety of applications such as image (co-) registration, stereo 
parallax matching for generation of digital elevation models, 
particle image velocimetry (PIV), or displacement 
measurements. 
The group of area-based matching techniques is the most widely 
used method due to its relative simplicity (Zitova and Flusser 
2003). A number of similarity criteria can be used for the 
matching process. Cross-correlation, in particular its normalised 
form which accounts for intensity variations in image 
sequences, is the most widely used due to its reliability and 
simplicity (Lewis 1995). The normalised cross-correlation 
(NCC) algorithm has been used to investigate earth surface 
mass movements such as glacier flow, rockglacier creep and 
land sliding in many empirical studies (Haug et al. 2010; Kaab 
and Vollmer 2000; Scambos et al. 1992). 
Although NCC has been documented to be simple and reliable, 
a number of drawbacks have been reported as well: Firstly, its 
precision is, in principle, limited to one pixel, and thus varying 
with the pixel size of the image data used. Secondly, NCC is 
sensitive to noise in the images. Such noise may result in wrong 
correlation maxima leading to mismatches. This problem is 
often partly addressed through image transformation (e.g. 
Fourier) in case of images with low signal-to-noise ratio (Lewis 
1995). Thirdly, NCC is sensitive to significant scale, rotation or 
shearing differences between the images to be correlated (Zhao 
et al. 2006). Due to this limitation, NCC is recommended in 
cases where the movement is mainly due to translation with 
limited rotation, scaling or shearing. A way to partly overcome 
this limitation of NCC is to orthorectify the images used before 
the matching (Kaab and Vollmer 2000). Fourthly, for the 
measurement to be reliable the displacement has to be greater 
than the mean error of the image (co-)registration. Improving 
NCC precision improves displacement accuracy twofold: firstly, 
it reduces image registration error; secondly, it improves the 
matching accuracy directly. 
To achieve sub-pixel precision in NCC, three approaches can be 
used. One is to improve the imaging system towards a higher 
spatial resolution. This approach is complicated by a number of
	        
Waiting...

Note to user

Dear user,

In response to current developments in the web technology used by the Goobi viewer, the software no longer supports your browser.

Please use one of the following browsers to display this page correctly.

Thank you.