The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences. Vol. XXXVII. Part Bl. Beijing 2008
138
Fig. 9 - Time-series of displacements of a sub-set of high-
coherence points (p>0.99), according to Fig. 8. On the upper
graphic, five points belonging to the dam top crest; on the lower,
three points that are vertically widespread
4.1 Data validation
At the same time of GBInSAR measurements, the dam was
under monitoring by a coordinatometer, whose results were
compared to IBIS-L results and exhibited a good agreement, i.e.
differences between measurements achieved by different
instrumentations during 24 hours have been compared, resulting
in discrepancies with a RMSE of ±0.2 mm (see Fig. 10).
Fig. 10 - IBIS-L single pixel displacement (green circles) on
the middle of the dam crest, compared to coordinatometer
measurements along the entire period of observation
5. CONCLUSIONS
The application of an innovative, radar-based measuring system
(IBIS-L by IDS, Italy) to static deformation of a large arch
gravity dam has been described in the paper together with the
system functioning principles.
The test results highlight very good performance of this sensor
coupled with the SAR technique in the measurement of slow
movements, if compared with standard monitoring instruments.
Achievements of this experimentation are very promising and
open new perspectives for static analysis of large dam
behaviour, and of other kinds of large constructions as well.
Indeed, instruments and sensors which have been applied so far
for measuring dam deformations feature an high accuracy and
reliability, even though only a limited number of points could
be observed. On the other hand, during this experimentation a
very huge number of monitored points has been measured
(some thousands) during a period of 37 hours. Also in case of
the restricted sub-set S0.99 of only points featuring very high
coherence, this account for more than 30 points which are
widespread on the whole dam downstream face. In addition, no
artificial reflectors are needed. The global behaviour of
measured displacements and a quality check based on a
comparison to readings from a coordinatometer have enhanced
an accuracy of this GBInSAR system under ±1 mm. At the
current state of the art, this cannot be achieved by other
instruments, considering that mountain environments where
dams are usually located might requirethe sensor positioning
very far from the structure to be monitored (also some hundreds
meters); obviously, this fact is a strong drawbacks for remote
displacement sensors (e.g. for robotic total stations or automatic
collimators), while IBIS-L can operate also from some
thouthands meters.
Moreover, the temporal data acquisition rate (9 minutes) and
the degree of automation are excellent, if compared to other
monitoring sensors. These characteristics make possible to use
GBInSAR systems for continuos monitoring purpose, and to
integrate them with other monitoring techniques
A second important achievement of this test concerns the
possibility by the end-users to adopt a commercial system, like
IBIS-L is, for the current practise of dam monitoring activities.
The presence of a simple GUI, the low number of parameters to
set up and the standardization of SAR processing, allow its use
also by non-skilled people in radar techniques.
However, the experimental and theoretical research in this field
needs further improvements. In particular, the precize
localization of control points is to be developed. Furthermore,
the integration between TLS and GBInSAR data is expected to
open to further interesting applications, where the former
system is able to detect lower frequency deformations with a
higher point density, while the latter is capable to monitor
higher frequency at a lower spatial resolution.
AKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Thanks go to A2A ATO-SIE (Grosio, Italy) for the availability
of the dam of Cancano Lake and for the cooperation during
experiments with the GBInSAR system.
REFERENCES
Alba, M., Fregonese, L., Prandi, F., Scaioni, M., and P. Valgoi,
2006. Structural Monitoring of a Large Dam by Terrestrial
Laser Scanning. IAPRSSIS, Vol. 36/5, pp. 6, on CDROM.
Bemardini, G., De Pasquale, G., Bicci, A., Marra, M., Coppi, F.,
Ricci, P. and M. Pieraccini, 2007a. Microwave interferometer
for ambient vibration measurements on civil engineering
structures: 1. Principles of the radar technique and laboratory