1152
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences. Vol. XXXVII. Part Bl. Beijing 2008
When we use under sampling there isn’t ground control points
in all places of high slope and height distributions of control
points are restricted. Number of ground control points are 44
and number of check points are 52. Figure 5 shows distribution
of control points.
Figure 5. Ground control points distribution in under sampling
Results of the experiments were shown in table 3. Regards to
this table we can conclude:
• Accuracies of check points have decreased in all
models because control points hanven’t good height
distribution and all points are placed in low height
levels. This shows that in under sampling case
accuracies for check points aren’t high.
• Approximately accuracies of control points have
improved in all models because all control points are
nearly in the same height level and fitting of rational
functions to these points was better.
• By increasing rational functions’ order, their accuracies
have improved such that third order rational functions
P2& F4
( ) have the best accuracy.
N.O.GCPs
N.O.CKPs
RMSECKPXYZ
(cm)
RMSECNPXYZ
(cm)
lorderRFM(P2#>4)
44
52
8.410
5.235
2orderRFM(P2^P4)
44
52
50.041
0.960
3orderRFM(P2#>4)
44
52
1.407
0.006
2orderRFM(P2=P4)
44
52
21.059
1.329
3orderRFM(P2=P4)
44
52
6.707
0.021
Inverse lorderRFM
(P2*P4)
44
52
1935.72
98.689
Inverse 2orderRFM
(P2^P4)
44
52
1014.16
2.496
Inverse 3orderRFM
(P2#>4)
44
52
Table 3. Results obtained from simulated data in under sampling
For the better analysis of residuals, first order rational functions
error vectors of X, Y and Z elements in optimum sampling, over
sampling and under sampling were shown in figure 6 and 7. For
seeing error vectors more obvious, some of these vectors were
shown. In all cases of sampling, rational functions’ errors in Z
direction are much more than X and Y directions, but the
errors in X direction are the same as Y direction. Regarding
these figures it can be see that maximum error is high, but we
saw in previous tables, the average error of first order ational
functions is approximately 6cm for optimum sampling and over
sampling and the error is nearly 10cm for under sampling.
(a)
(c)
Figure 6. Planimetric error vectors of first order rational functions in a) optimum sampling b) over sampling c) under sampling