The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences. Vol. XXXVII. Part Bl. Beijing 2008
1328
Fig. 11: colour coded height model extracted from aerial
images (left) and from Cartosat-1 images (right)
In Fig. 11 the extracted height models are shown; the software
used for the DEM generation are respectively ERDAS v. 9.1 for
the aerial block and RPCDEM for Cartosat-1 stereo pairs. The
two software packages respond in different ways in the lake
zone, in fact ERDAS applies an automatic filtering function so
that it is able to assign an elevation even in the lake areas, on
the contrary the matching achieved by DPLX did not recognize
homologous points for the two images, due to the fact that no
contrast was available on the lakes; therefore the elevation of
those points was not extracted by RPCDEM.
Furthermore the accuracy of Cartosat-1 DSM has been checked,
with respect to the reference DSM over different terrain types:
open areas and urban areas; thus the overall scene has been
divided in several selected regions. The analyses have been
performed both for the digital surface models directly obtained
from the images, and for the digital elevation models, obtained
filtering the original DSMs with the Hannover software
RASCOR.
The selected open regions are not completely flat zones,
because they still contain sparse buildings and groups of trees,
nontheless the accuracy obtained was in the range of the
standard deviation of the height.
Regarding the urban areas the discrepancies with the reference
DSM are bigger; in these areas the smoothing effect of
Cartosat-1 is more evident, in fact, while the DSM results
higher than the reference over the streets, it tends to smooth the
edges of the buildings, as it is is shown by the profiles in Fig 12;
on the contrary after filtering the profiles are similar and the
smoothing effects disappear (Fig. 13).
Fig. 12: profiles through a Cartosat-1 DSM and the reference
DSM from aerial images an urban area
Fig. 13: profiles through a Cartosat-1 DEM and the reference
DEM from aerial images an urban area
In the Fig. 14 the differential DSM of an open area and an
urban area are shown; the differential DSM is obtained by the
comparison beetwen the DSM reference and the Cartosat-1
DSM generated with RPCDEM using the SISAR RPC (Fig. 14).
.00 RED
.00 BRÖBN
.00 YELLOW
.00 GREEN
.00 GREEN-BL OE
.00 BLUE
.00 VIOLETT
Fig. 14: Differential DSM of open area (left) and urban area
(right)
4. CONCLUSION
Results stemming from the geometric reconstruction of
Cartosat-1 imagery shows that accuracy is at GSD level in
horizontal components and at about 2-3 m in vertical one.
The SISAR results demonstrate that RPCs, generated by SISAR
software, permit high performance for image orientation,
achieving results close to the geometric reconstruction. A
particular core was devoted into the estimable coefficient
selection; by now the usual strategy is the mainly based on
Tichonov regularization, on the contrary, in this work a
different innovative method was used, based on the Singular
Value Decomposition (SVD) and QR that can reliably handle
the rank deficient matrices, without require an empirical
evaluation of the regularization parameter. This selection allows
to use a number of coefficients lower than the standard number
used in the third order polynomial (78 RPC).
Digital height models have been generated by means of
Cartosat-1 stereo pairs. The orientation of the models in any
case was possible with sub-pixel accuracy by bias corrected
RPC-solution. In any case for flat terrain the height accuracy is
better than 1 GSD for the x-parallax or 4m. After filtering for
elements not belonging to the bare ground the vertical accuracy
for flat terrain is not less than 3.2m corresponding to x-parallax