The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences. Vol. XXXVII. Part B4. Beijing 2008
1336
A basic-point to define a traditional analogue photo campaign,
is the camera frame or the image-extend, meaning the resulting
area on the ground that is covered through one image by the
analogue camera.
All “full size” analogue aerial cameras use the same frame size,
defined by the film size of 23cm by 23cm, and by that also
represent the same image-extend on the ground - given a
specific camera lens system (focal length) and a specific flying
height.
This is not the case for the digital cameras, where CCD’s has
substituted the traditional film-media. There are big differences
on how the cameras CCD’s are combined and arranged into the
final image-frame. And by this, also different resulting image-
extends.
Because there is no exact conversion from one single analogue
image-extend to the various digital CCD frame image-extends.
The term image-extend is no longer used in the specification
for a KMS digital photo campaign.
3.2 Image-scale / Flying height
For an analogue photo-campaign, it is also necessary to define
the two interacting parameters image-scale and flying-height.
Image-scale is the most commonly used and exact term, which
through a predefined camera-lens-system (and image-extend),
also specifies the exact flying height.
For a digital image campaign, image-scale and flying-height are
also interconnected and by so it is only needed to specify one of
them.
The image-scale specification for digital cameras, are the
definition of “ground sampling distance” (GSD). The GSD
defines what size on the ground that has to be represented in
one pixel. Normally the GSD are specified as “X centimetres”
meaning that one image pixel (must) represent “X centimetres
by X centimetres” on the ground (flat ground).
Specification of GSD is sufficient and preferable to substitute
the traditionally definition of both image-scale and flying-
height. Using the GSD, the specification is neutral to which
digital camera could be used. Different cameras with different
camera-lens parameters will adapt the requested GSD, by doing
the data-collection from different flying heights.
3.3 Coverage / Flight lines
By the fact that the different digital cameras consist of different
image extents, the cameras do also cover various areas on the
ground, given a specific GSD. This is also the case when
compared to an analogue camera.
A transition from analogue to digital image campaigns, or “year
by year” transitions between digital camera types, will therefore
cause ongoing fluctuations in “ground coverage” on images and
by that also fluctuations in “number of images and number of
flight-lines” needed to cover a specified image-campaign.
When the production, as for KMS, is highly repetitive and
based on tenders with possible changing contractors, the image
footprint and number of images for each campaign are very
seldom constant over years.
3.4 Summary
At KMS, the first revision of the tender material to adapt a
digital production, resulted in exclusion of all references of
image extends, camera lens system, flying height and image
scale. Instead the GSD “ground sampling distance” was
introduced and substituted to describe matters where the
excluded specifications were used.
These matters do in some ways simplify the tender, by
focussing on only GSD as the primary specification of a photo
campaign. But other parts, as missing continuity in technology,
image positioning and image extend (by different camera-types)
could cause a more complicated tender evaluation and
production QA.
In table 1 is shown an overview of these discussed elements.
Subject
Analogue
Digital
Image extent
Same for all
camera-types
Differs for each
camera-type
Flying height
Exact for each
image scale
Differs for each
camera-type
Image scale /
GSD
Image scale...
exact
GSD.... exact
Coverage
Exact for each
image scale
Differs for each
camera-type
Table 1 : aspects on analoug/digital camera-types
4. EVALUATION OF WORKFLOW AND
END-PRODUCTS
In the production workflow, the different phases of planning,
tender, data collection, logistics, data processing,
documentation etc. have all shown elements, where the use of
the digital camera technology causes serious considerations and
serious need for changes.
These different workflow-phases of the digital image data
collection will be discussed. Critical points and recommended
practical solutions will be presented and argued.
4.1 Planning
The initial revision of the KMS photo campaign tender-material,
was focused on the referred matters presented in section 3. To
allow data capturing with digital cameras, all references of
image-extend, camera-objective, flying-height and image-scale
had to be removed from the tender material and substituted with
the term “ground sampling distance” (GSD).
To consider, is also the effective “ground coverage” of each
image, which, in case of digital production, is depending on the
camera type used by the chosen contractor. Therefore a pre
flight planning of image positions and image frames, should no
longer to be part of the tender material.
The pre-planning was earlier produced and estimated by KMS.
Results was given as information to the tenders, as input for
there calculations and price-estimations.
Planning now has to wait until the contractor and thereby the
camera type has been defined. This means that each tender now
have to do his own pre-planning, to estimate the necessary
workload and a price.