280
SYMPOSIUM PHOTO INTERPRETATION, DELFT 1962
and mosaics are used to give an overall assessment. This method is primarily
used in urban analysis [44]. In these cases no interpretation is attempted
other than preliminary mental recognition of the major surface elements and
their juxtaposition.
Stereoscopic interpretation of dynamic forms has resulted in differing tech
niques. Occasionally, the classification that has been used is so broad (3 to 5
units) that despite the scale, errors due to recent change do not significantly
invalidate type boundaries [31, 32, 37, 39]. Another technique is to map with
a more detailed classification, and correct as far as possible from fieldwork [29,
32, 35, 36, 39]. This method is sometimes used to the extreme, where all land
use data is from fieldwork, and the air photographs are used only to outline
field boundaries and forest areas [29, 54]. The most desirable method is to map
from recent photographs at large scales (1 : 20,000 to 1 : 10,000). This has
been found to allow the use of the World Land Use Classification with a
minimum of fieldwork and with a maximum of accuracy [29, 54, 59]. Fre
quently it also allows use of a more critical sub-division, such as that between
orchards and vineyards.
This leads directly to sequential studies. As outlined earlier, Canada is
fortunate in this regard and sometimes it has been possible to obtain two
coverages of air-photographs on which significant changes to the landscape
have occurred. A typical study was carried out in the Niagara District [21]
where the encroachments of urban sprawl on high grade farm land between
1934 and 1954 were plotted. The interpretation, coupled with census data,
used the easily recognisable road grid as a base unit. The results were expressed
as percentages per unit area and tabulated on punch cards for electronic
computation.
The immense value of sequential study has become apparent in other areas
of dynamic photo interpretation. Fluctuations in glacier volume, firn line, and
crevasse patterns over 10 and 20 year periods are being plotted [54]. The
effects of shoreline erosion and deposition on sea [12], river and lake shores [60]
have also been traced. The main difficulty in these studies is the contrast in
scales and season between the two sets of available photography. In the case
of the glacier fluctuation it includes comparison between obliques taken from
20,000 feet above sea level with recent verticals taken from 35,000 feet above
sea level with a negative scale of 1 mile : 1 inch. The difficulties are resolved
by use of a perspective grid, and optical scale reductions until static points
coincide, when finally glacier fluctuations can be measured. Such studies have
brought an increasing realization of the advantages of a planned sequential
study. Very few of these have been carried out in Canada, though large scale
planned sequential land use interpretation is projected for the Peace River
area [54] where power developments are expected to alter land use patterns
markedly. A small scale planned sequential study is proposed in the vicinity of the
new Saskatchewan Dam [54], where increased irrigation possibilities and newly
available power are expected to have considerable impact on present land use.