64
SYMPOSIUM PHOTO INTERPRETATION, DELFT 1962
present study provided an opportunity to look at confidence for rights and
wrongs as a function of photo mode and of photo quality. For each object
identified, the interpreter assigned a percentage that represents what he con
siders to be the likelihood that the object is correctly identified. Table 7
shows the results obtained for high photo quality. Note that the right responses
are invariably associated with greater confidence than the wrong responses
and significantly so in three out of the four modes. This significant difference
for confidence in right and wrong responses carries over to the total. Similar
findings are obtained for the low photo quality as can be seen in table 8.
Table 7. Percent confidence for rights and wrongs by mode for high photo
quality
Right
Wrong
Positive Transparency *
57
46
Negative Transparency
60
56
Stereo Print *
73
61
Non-Stereo Print
75
62
Total *
65
56
* Right-Wrong differences significant at
P < .05.
Table 8. Percent confidence for
rights and wrongs by mode for low photo
quality
Right
Wrong
Positive Transparency
67
64
Negative Transparency *
61
44
Stereo Print *
73
59
Non-Stereo Print
66
56
Total *
68
56
* Right-Wrong differences significant at
P < .05.
When we compare total mean confidence for the right responses for the
high and low photo qualities we find that they are substantially the same 65
and 68 percent, respectively. This is also true for the mean confidence for the
wrong responses. This implies that across the four modes, the probability of
correctness of identification based on confidence is the same for both high
and low photo qualities. However these findings do not rule out the possibility
that for a given mode this probability could be greater than for another.
Length of viewing time
We have already seen some evidence that accuracy goes down and com
pleteness up as a function of time. We have also noted interpreter performance
with the exception of the tenuous finding for 30-minute completeness at low
photo quality is not affected by photo mode. On the other hand, there are
significant performance differences attributable to photo quality. A perform
ance over time comparison was therefore only made for photo quality.